Stories behind memorable albums of the 1970s as told by the artists

Hall & Oates: First-hand perspective on how their roles evolved within the band

Daryl Hall and John Oates headlines the inaugural Hoagie Nation Festival May 27, 2017, in their hometown of Philadelphia. (Photo by Mike Morsch)

Daryl Hall and John Oates headlined the inaugural Hoagie Nation Festival May 27, 2017, in their hometown of Philadelphia.
(Photo by Mike Morsch)

Seeing Daryl Hall and John Oates headline the inaugural Hoagie Nation Festival in Philly May 27 reminded me of a portion of the last interview I did with Oates. It was about how each of their roles in the band had evolved throughout their careers.

There is a perspective out there – one with which I vehemently disagree – that Oates is some sort of second banana to Hall. There was even a short-lived television show called “Garfunkel and Oates” that is described as being about “two famous rock-and-roll second bananas.” (As an aside, Oates himself played a porn shop clerk in one episode and there was a hilarious off-color running joke on the show that referenced Oates’ famous 1970s mustache.)

In a dozen interviews over the past decade, I’ve talked to Oates about almost everything Hall & Oates and everything solo Oates. He’s what I’d describe as the perfect interview subject: articulate, has a detailed recollection about songs and events, is a good storyteller, never dodges a question, polite, gracious, media savvy and a genuinely nice guy. He’s the kind of guy you’d want to hang with and just listen to him tell stories. I consider myself lucky to have had him share many of those stories with me and I’ve included them in three volumes of The Vinyl Dialogues. (He’s also got a book out titled “Change of Seasons” which includes many more of those great stories.)

(Photo by Mike Morsch)

(Photo by Mike Morsch)

But the one subject I’d never broached with Oates – because I wasn’t quite sure how he felt about it and didn’t want to offend – was this “second banana” hooey. How did that perspective happen? Did it bother him?

In one interview I had with Daryl Hall, he had briefly mentioned that when the band started to hit really big in the early 1980s, “our roles within the band changed.” He didn’t elaborate and I didn’t pursue any further line of questioning. But in my interviews with both Hall and Oates, neither has shown anything but the utmost respect for the other.

So during my last interview with Oates, I felt comfortable enough – thanks in large part to him seemingly being comfortable with me and my questions over the years – to ask him about how his role in the band had evolved and if any of the second banana perspective had bothered him.

The short answer: It doesn’t.

What is comes down to was that many of the duo’s commercially successful songs – “Sara Smile,” “Rich Girl,” “Wait for Me,” “Kiss on My List,” “You Make My Dreams,” “Private Eyes,” “Maneater,” “One on One” – all feature Hall on the lead vocals.

John Oates and Charlie DeChant. (Photo by Mike Morsch)

John Oates and Charlie DeChant.
(Photo by Mike Morsch)

“It happened naturally,” said Oates. “In the very beginning, it was a much more equitable thing between Daryl and I in terms of who was singing lead. There were a few singles in the early days that were released with me singing lead that never caught on.” (If you want a couple of examples of H&O songs that should have been bigger hits with Oates singing lead, look no further than the “Abandoned Luncheonette” album and the Oates-penned songs “Had I Known You Better Then” and “Las Vegas Turnaround,” the latter of which they still play in many of their live shows to this day, although it wasn’t included Saturday night in the Hoagie Nation Festival setlist.)

It’s all about lack of ego, according to Oates.

“At that point, if I was ruled by ego, I might have said, ‘OK, I don’t want to be involved in something like this’ and I would have left,” said Oates. “But I always accepted that Daryl was such an exceptional singer and such a unique talent that it didn’t really surprise me, to be honest with you, when his voice cut the way it cut through the radio. It has a quality. It’s a natural gift that he happens to have that I evidently don’t. So be it.”

Oates said that he then became more involved in some of what he called “things that aren’t so flashy and glamorous that people don’t see” with the band. Things like the studio production, onstage lighting, sound staging and some of the other technical aspects of putting on live shows.

(Photo by Mike Morsch)

(Photo by Mike Morsch)

“I always viewed a partnership as a partnership. In any partnership, I don’t care if it’s marriage or a work partnership, you have to compromise on a lot of levels. So I’ve just accepted that. It was OK with me,” said Oates. “To be honest, I don’t need that in my life, that reaffirmation from the public. That doesn’t matter that much to me. So I guess in a way, it was really lucky that Daryl found me.”

Just to provide context, that last line was said by Oates with tongue firmly planted in cheek and with a chuckle.

But there isn’t any question – at least in my mind – that even though both Hall and Oates have pursued their solo projects over the past several years, they still like performing together. And that was evident at the Hoagie Nation Festival in their hometown.

“That’s the thing about Daryl and I that people really don’t understand or realize – that we are very unique people. We’ve grown up together from the time we were 18 years old. We’ve accepted each other’s idiosyncrasies, neuroses, good points and bad points. We don’t air dirty laundry and we learned how to deal with each other and how to make it work so that each of us feels satisfied and wants to continue doing it. It’s a very complex and subtle thing that is almost impossible to describe,” said Oates.

“The point is, we’ve really been sensitive to each other. We kind of inherently know what each person needs to keep this thing going and that’s why we’re still together.”


Timothy B. Schmit keeps on tryin’ and Havana crowd head over heels for him


Adding another wonderful Father’s Day memory, with a soundtrack by Jimmy Beaumont and the Skyliners


  1. Leslie Robinson

    Hello Mike,
    My name is Leslie Robinson and I have a website/internet radio music station called that plays song hits that spans from the 1970’s through the 1980’s. I cover all the pop,R&B,adult contemporary(yacht rock),smooth jazz,classic rock from that era of music and my favorite artist of all are of course Daryl Hall and John Oates. I am a GREAT admirer of the 70’s and 80’s music as that’s the music I grew up with.(i’m 52 years old) and I have different and unique perspectives on how growing up in Philly and how music has shaped my life. I am a GREAT admirer of your work and I would LOVE to get together with you on a project to talk about this more. Please get in touch with as I would like to run some things by you to see what you think. Thank you in advance for your time. looking forward to hearing from you!

    • Thanks for the kind words, Leslie. Thanks so much for reading my stuff. I’ve sent you a private message on Facebook.- M2

    • Joel

      What’s the station? I’d like to check it out.

      • It was a short-lived series in 2014, only one season and eight episodes, on IFC (Independent Film Channel). It’s available on Netflix, I think. – M2

  2. I like to listen to Hall & Oates, because my father listens to them for about 30 years. Qualitatively made music!

  3. Best duo of all time.There’s none better

  4. Barry Harris

    Hi. I was fortunate to have worked on the H20 album while on staff at Electric Lady Studios in the 80’s. My role was as assistant engineer to Hugh Padgham during the mixing of the record. John was always in the producer’s chair overseeing both the production and technical sides of the entire process. It was a great experience to work with John. Just a great guy. And it wasn’t a hardship watching Daryl lay down all those great vocals.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén